October Fall was a piano-fueled pop punk band from Chicago, Illinois during 2003-2007. They came together in the summer of 2003, with Pat D'Andrea and Clark Harrison as the original members. These two originally played together under the name "Silver Lining". Soon after, the rest of the band was added: Nick Coleman , Owen Toomey , and Jack Marin . Nick Coleman was replaced by Nick Scalise , and Jack Marin was replaced by Greg Shanahan .