Tip:
Highlight text to annotate it
X
or about to do is give you the anatomy
other right-wing ally I love doing this
we should make a permanent segment out a bit Glenn Beck
on his show today said this the Constitution
is not the Bible the Constitution
was born out %uh the Bible 30 percent
30 percent up everything in our founding documents comes from one book the book
Deuteronomy
1 30 percent if you don't know what
it came from you certainly can't repair it
so whenever I hear something as silly
and stupid and inaccurate as that
my initial response is always how the *** can you say that without doing
Wii did you know research are you just completely talking out of your ***
quote the false statement is based on a nineteen eighty-four study
by a University of Houston professor who found that
among the documents published during the founding
era the Bible was the most frequently cited source
but that was largely because most of the citations came from sermons reprinted
as pamphlets hundreds of sermons were reprinted during the era
amounting to at least 10 percent up all pamphlets
published okay so that's it
the starting point right there keep that in mind that is
a loose a levy what this is based off now remember
he's already wrong because we're talking about arm
the idea that over 10 percent %uh all citations during those times in the past
were Bible citations and again that makes perfect sense his back in a time
you know we're still majority religious today imagine a religious people were
back then
when you know the Enlightenment science education a lot stuff was
at a very minimal level right and but
so it makes sense that back then most everything cited not for the
Constitution again that's the key point here not for the Constitution
just love the majority the things that were published works back then they had
are a little bit over 10 percent the citations were from the Bible
so that's the first point in how he came to saying this all along comes
Beck's historian a guy named David Barton who we've talked about on the
show and we've done stories about him before too
he is most known 4
publishing a book about jefferson that was given the title
the least accurate history book in print
from I think it was history news network says the kinda guy that we're dealing
with here
and he said back in 2010 quote
34 percent up the identifiable quotes from the thousands
up documents that were published during the founding era came from the Bible
in Deuteronomy was the most frequently cited book among those quotes
so you saw step number one was the
is study that said a little over 10 percent other quotes from all the works
back then were
but Bible citations right step number two is
Beck's fake historian comes in kicks that number up to 34 percent
okay insight i Deuteronomy is the most commonly quoted one
and then step number three is when that comes along and according a right wing
watch quote
orderly misrepresents this time and again in order to claim that
one-third of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence
came directly out of the book up Deuteronomy okay so goes from a little
over 10 percent for all the works
to thirty-four percent for all the works to
a 34 percent of the Constitution in the Declaration of Independence
art dealer ronnie there's the anatomy of a right-wing lie
you take something that's like thats
thats totally different okay take something is totally different
and vaguely loosely kind of not really related to the comment that you're about
to make
you remove a two level so you do a game a telephone okay so many lies in the
middle and then you come up with the final I you driving home
ladies and gentlemen I give you the way the right-wingers think okay
there's no hey lemme factor check this let me go to Google me do my own
research before I open my big fat stupid *** mouth
its I don't know I heard my *** fake historians say something somewhat
similar to this even though he made up a lot of it now make up even more been
I'll say it
and then how many times have we gone over man I've given you
arm the *** quotes of thomas jefferson
arm Ben Franklin Thomas Paine
and others the a a lot of the founding fathers were deists
certainly most the well known ones were deists and they were openly hostile to
Christianity in many cases
ok I've given you the quote on a show before you guys probably *** tired
hearing them I want
you know bore you with them again now but also just the basic fact that
how many times are the Constitution reference the word God 0
the Bible 0 Deuteronomy 0 Jesus
0 how many times as a reference religion
once in the Establishment Clause to say we shall not
established by religion to say there can be no religious test for office
okay so all it would take is from either read
the *** Constitution or to do a little bit a research online and you
would realize that he sounds like such an
idiot man it is such a made-up idea
in in the end when you actually look back at the reality of it
n what the point I'm trying to get across here is
this is the level of scrutiny and the level of skepticism that you have to
have
all the time especially when you're listening to
you know right-wing pundits talk because it's always like I heard something from
somebody else from somebody else they're old not trustworthy people but I like
them so I'm just gonna take it out with myself a little bit and boom
the end result is you know Jesus wrote the Constitution and ronald reagan
the ronald reagan's ghost is still on the white house