Tip:
Highlight text to annotate it
X
Finding Hope: Nurse Navigation
Hi my name is Carrie Callahan and I am a Nurse Navigator, a term you may not have heard before,
in part because it is relatively new in terms of the history of nursing.
The term “patient navigation” was first created in 1990 by Harold Freeman, who partnered
with the American Cancer Society to establish the first patient navigation program in the
country in the Harlem neighborhood of New York City. The original program was designed
to increase the rates of breast cancer screening in low-income women by removing barriers that
these women often encountered. Nurses and other health care workers assigned to these
women helped the patients overcome financial, communication, psychological and transportation
barriers while smoothing their coordination of appointments. The service demonstrated
that patients who partnered with these health care professionals had positive outcomes.
Women in the program took advantage of the screening, were diagnosed with earlier and
more treatable cancers, and had greater access to treatment. It was an excellent method to
reduce barriers that patients may encounter in their local community.
Since that time, the model has been adapted to several types of cancer. In addition, the
model has expanded from just screening and detection to assist patients through the entire
health care experience, from prevention, early detection, diagnosis, treatments and supportive
or end of life care.
My background is fairly typical of other nurse navigators. I began my career as a registered
nurse on a general surgery unit and became a nurse clinician, expanding my depth of patient
care. Working closely with physicians, patients and hospital staff to coordinate patient care
was extremely rewarding. However, the care that was coordinated was usually within the
scope of the patient’s stay or immediately thereafter.
Some surgeons whose patients I had provided care for recruited me as their first nurse
navigator when they opened a multidisciplinary Liver and Pancreas Tumor Clinic. My job was
to coordinate the care of patients in a timely and thorough fashion, from the time that they
were referred to the clinic, through treatment and in follow up visits. Although each patient’s
case was unique, it was not unusual to coordinate the patient’s visits with up to six different
specialists – medical oncologists, radiation oncologists, surgeons, interventional radiologists,
dietitians and social workers. My role as the patient's advocate and caregiver evolved
as I determined their needs. After a few years in this clinic, I was offered a similar position
in a private practice that provided complex surgical care. While providing care in this
setting is slightly different, my philosophy of care is the same. I still care for patients
who need expedited care delivered with the utmost compassion.
While there are published guidelines and job descriptions of nurse navigators, the job
varies from day to day, sometimes minute by minute as you interact with patients, families
and physicians and determine immediate and long-range needs.
For the patients, the navigation portion of my job begins when the patient enters the
system as symptoms present or abnormal test results occur. The physicians recommend a
course of action for diagnosis but we can also use protocols to refer the patients to
other specialists for timely diagnosis. As treatment plans are created, the nurse navigator
works with the patient’s and clinicians’ schedules to coordinated further testing,
complex treatments and supportive therapies. In addition, if the patient participates in
clinical trials or research, the nurse navigator often coordinates all of that activity as
well.
But our roles reach well beyond appointment scheduling. We look after the patient as a
whole. For example, it is not unusual for us to make travel arrangements for patients
and their family members if they are coming in for surgery or other treatments. We also
help connect the patient to the right individuals if there are financial concerns. One of the
things I did as a navigator in the clinic was to develop and maintain an up-to-date
working list of local and national resources to share with patients and their families
for all of their needs.
We are often the source of information for the patients. Many times, the patients are
not medical professionals and have a limited understanding of their condition, the diagnostic
tests or the medications and other treatments. Occasionally there is a need to educate patients
about the nontraditional or non-research based treatment options that may attract vulnerable
patients and that have potentially no survival benefit. Providing patients with my time to
answer their questions and supplementing it with easily understandable information that
they could share with friends and family is a requirement of the nurse navigator.
But perhaps my most crucial role with patients is helping them through their cancer diagnosis
and treatment by just being there for them. As a nurse navigator, I play several different
roles, including friend, listener, confidante, daughter, or other family member. Fairly consistently,
however, you have to remain calm, compassionate and sympathetic, always offering hope and
a positive outlook.
This was especially true due to the nature of this specialty clinic. Every day, I cared
for patients who faced what most would consider scary diagnoses or either pancreatic or liver
cancer. The patients entrusted me to help them through this process of a diagnosis and
the creation of a treatment plan as fast as humanly possible. While the specialists were
not always available for questions or concerns throughout the day, as the patient’s nurse
navigator, I was readily available with an open door for whatever I could do to make
their lives easier. At times, I provided appointment scheduling and direction, provided clinical
information about their disease or the medications they took, explained the symptoms they were
experiencing, talked to them about recovery expectations or gave them information on financial
assistance. The patients were comforted to have someone guide them through the maze that
is the medical system.
And a wider group of patients agree. The Advisory Board of Oncology Round Table in 2007 polled
a group of oncology patients based on criteria “Nice to Have versus Need to Have” As
you can see demonstrated in the graph, the availability of a Nurse Navigator was the
3rd in line as a priority “Need” with Multidisciplinary Care and Symptom Management
in the forefront. Patients and families place a high value on supportive services that are
provided by the Navigator.
The benefits of the role also extend the physicians and other clinicians involved in caring for
that patients. Physicians want the best care for the patients and at the same time want
that care to be a highly efficient process for them and their patients. Physicians can
relate to the improved communication between all members: the nurse navigator, the patient,
the physician and other physician specialists. When a nurse navigator is following a group
of patients there is a definite ownership and follow-through on the physician’s medical
recommendations. The nurse navigator is also able to field procedural, testing, medication
and symptom management calls for the physician, which relieves their work load. The nurse
navigator is also able to conduct nursing assessments to determine the need for patients
to be admitted to the hospital or a transfer from one hospital to another hospital, and
to determine if an emergency room visit is in order. The polling of physicians found
that nurse navigators to be an essential part of the health care process that yields high
quality of care that enables the best patient outcomes.
Over the last 20 years there has been a considerable increase in the number of patient navigation
programs across the country to facilitate the care for patients. Federal and private
funding has ensured the survival of this proven worthwhile endeavor of patient navigation.
A process that assists in the participation of cancer screening, early diagnosis and adherence
to follow up care for all populations hasn’t gone unnoticed. Originally, the populations
that the navigator targeted were low income and underserved and then it progressed to
the entire cancer arena. Today, the patient navigator is coordinating care for many different
chronic disease processes that are not necessarily cancer driven.
As a result, physicians are beginning to demand the increased use of these nursing specialists.
A recent Wall Street Journal article on Patient Navigation quoted that the American College
of Surgeons issued new standards this year that will require all Cancer Centers to offer
patient navigation services by 2015 in order to meet accreditation standards. And with
increasing numbers of survivors, the population of nurse navigators is likely to grow as well.
I’d like to close this talk by providing just a few case studies of how I was able
to affect positive change in a few my patients’ lives through the work I do each day.
In one instance, I was able to save a patient almost $3,000 a month. This individual had
insurance but had unfortunately run of available funds to cover an injectable medication. The
patient was unaware that the pharmaceutical company offered a patient assistance program.
After completing a few forms related to the treatment plan and lack of coverage, the medication
arrived within two weeks of completing the necessary paperwork; the patient now receives
the medication free of charge. The solution to his financial problem was a matter of knowing
what resources are available and how to go about utilizing them.
Another patient called to schedule a consultation at a surgeon’s office when the surgeon happened
to be from out of town, approximately 2 ½ hours away. After screening the patient, it
was determined that other workup needed to be conducted before a treatment plan could
be established. The ability to facilitate the patient’s care is essential when they
are not from the local area. The patient’s consultation experience included an appointment
with the surgeon, the medical oncologist, same day imaging and laboratory testing. Local
overnight accommodations at a discounted rate were available as an option. The patient and
their family were grateful not to have had made multiple trips to the area wasting time
and money on their travels. The patient also left the appointment with a treatment plan
in hand.
Finally, I was the nurse navigator for a cancer patient whose daughter was to be married in
a few weeks out of state. After speaking with the surgeon and based on his status and medical
treatment plan, travel was not going to be possible. I was able to facilitate plans at
the hospital so that he could be there to give his daughter away in matrimony. All the
plans took place over one week and the outcome was unforgettable for all.
I’d like to thank you for the opportunity to discuss nurse navigators and their role
in providing coordinated, multidisciplinary care.